| Year |
Player [Bold=Voted in by public] |
Pos |
Notes |
| 2011 | Matt Kemp | OF | |
| Clayton Kershaw | P | |
| Andre Ethier | OF | Replaced OF Shane Victorino |
| 2010 | Jonathan Broxton | RP | |
| Andre Ethier | OF | |
| Rafael Furcal | SS | Replaced Jose Reyes |
| Hong-Chih Kuo | P | Replaced OF Jason Heyward |
| 2009 | Chad Billingsley | P | |
| Jonathan Broxton | RP | Did not pitch |
| Orlando Hudson | 2B | |
| 2008 | Russell Martin | C | |
| 2007 | Russell Martin | C | |
| Brad Penny | P | |
| Takashi Saito | RP | |
| 2006 | Nomar Garciaparra | SS | Final vote winner |
| Brad Penny | P | |
| 2005 | Cesar Izturis | SS | Replaced by Jimmy Rollins |
| Jeff Kent | 2B | |
| 2004 | Eric Gagne | RP | |
| Paul Lo Duca | C | |
| 2003 | Kevin Brown | P | Replaced by Dontrelle Willis |
| Eric Gagne | RP | |
| Paul Lo Duca | C | |
| 2002 | Chan Ho Park | P | |
| Jeff Shaw | P | |
| 2001 | Kevin Brown | P | |
| Gary Sheffield | OF | |
| 2000 | Kevin Brown | P | |
| Gary Sheffield | OF | |
| 1999 | Jeff Shaw | P | |
| Gary Sheffield | OF | |
| 1998 | Mike Piazza | C | |
| 1997 | Mike Piazza | C | |
| Todd Worrell | RP | Did not pitch |
| 1996 | Mike Piazza | C | |
| Todd Worrell | RP | Did not pitch |
| 1995 | Raul Mondesi | OF | |
| Hideo Nomo | P | Starting pitcher |
| Mike Piazza | C | |
| Jose Offerman | SS | |
| Todd Worrell | RP | Did not pitch |
| 1994 | Mike Piazza | C | |
| 1993 | Mike Piazza | C | |
| 1992 | Mike Sharperson | 3B | |
| 1991 | Brett Butler | OF | |
| Mike Morgan | P | |
| Eddie Murray | 1B | |
| Juan Samuel | 2B | |
| Darryl Strawberry | OF | Injured |
| 1990 | Ramon Martinez | P | |
| Mike Scioscia | C | |
| 1989 | Orel Hershiser | P | Did not pitch |
| Jay Howell | RP | |
| Willie Randolph | 2B | |
| Mike Scioscia | C | |
| 1988 | Orel Hershiser | P | |
| Kirk Gibson | OF | Declined |
| 1987 | Pedro Guerrero | | |
| Orel Hershiser | P | |
| 1986 | Steve Sax | 2B | |
| Fernando Valenzuela | P | |
| 1985 | Pedro Guerrero | | Injured |
| Fernando Valenzuela | P | |
| 1984 | Mike Marshall | P | Did not pitch |
| Fernando Valenzuela | P | |
| 1983 | Pedro Guerrero | 3B | |
| Steve Sax | 2B | |
| Fernando Valenzuela | P | Did not pitch |
| 1982 | Dusty Baker | OF | |
| Steve Howe | P | |
| Steve Sax | 2B | |
| Fernando Valenzuela | P | |
| 1981 | Dusty Baker | OF | |
| Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Pedro Guerrero | OF | |
| Burt Hooton | P | |
| Davey Lopes | 2B | |
| Fernando Valenzuela | P | Starting pitcher |
| 1980 | Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Davey Lopes | 2B | |
| Jerry Reuss | P | |
| Bill Russell | SS | |
| Reggie Smith | OF | |
| Bob Welch | P | |
| 1979 | Ron Cey | 3B | |
| Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Davey Lopes | 2B | |
| 1978 | Ron Cey | 3B | |
| Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Tommy John | P | Did not pitch |
| Davey Lopes | 2B | |
| Rick Monday | OF | |
| Reggie Smith | OF | |
| 1977 | Ron Cey | 3B | |
| Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Reggie Smith | OF | |
| Don Sutton | P | Starting pitcher |
| 1976 | Ron Cey | 3B | |
| Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Rick Rhoden | P | |
| Bill Russell | SS | |
| 1975 | Ron Cey | 3B | |
| Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Mike Marshall | P | Did not pitch |
| Andy Messersmith | P | Did not pitch |
| Don Sutton | P | |
| Jimmy Wynn | OF | |
| 1974 | Ron Cey | 3B | |
| Steve Garvey | 1B | |
| Mike Marshall | P | |
| Andy Messersmith | P | Starting pitcher |
| Jimmy Wynn | OF | |
| 1973 | Jim Brewer | P | |
| Willie Davis | OF | |
| Manny Mota | OF | |
| Claude Osteen | P | |
| Bill Russell | SS | |
| Don Sutton | P | |
| 1972 | Don Sutton | P | |
| 1971 | Willie Davis | OF | |
| 1970 | Billy Grabarkewitz | 3B | |
| Claude Osteen | P | |
| 1969 | Bill Singer | P | |
| 1968 | Don Drysdale | P | Starting Pitcher |
| Tom Haller | C | |
| 1967 | Don Drysdale | P | |
| Claude Osteen | P | |
| 1966 | Sandy Koufax | P | Starting pitcher |
| Jim Lefebvre | 2B | |
| Phil Regan | RP | Replaced Bob Gibson |
| Maury Wills | SS | |
| 1965 | Don Drysdale | P | |
| Sandy Koufax | P | |
| Maury Wills | SS | |
| 1964 | Don Drysdale | P | Starting pitcher |
| Sandy Koufax | P | Did not pitch |
| 1963 | Tommy Davis | OF | |
| Don Drysdale | P | |
| Sandy Koufax | P | Did not pitch |
| Maury Wills | SS | Did not play |
| 1962 | Tommy Davis | OF | |
| (two | Don Drysdale | P | Starting pitcher |
| games) | Sandy Koufax | P | Did not pitch |
| Johnny Podres | P | Starting pitcher |
| Johnny Roseboro | C | Did not play |
| Maury Wills | SS | MVP |
| 1961 | Don Drysdale | P | Starting pitcher |
| (two | Sandy Koufax | P | |
| games) | Johnny Roseboro | C | Did not play |
| Maury Wills | SS | |
| 1960 | Norm Larker | 1B | |
| (two | Charlie Neal | SS | |
| games) | Johnny Podres | P | |
| 1959 | Don Drysdale | P | Starting pitcher |
| (two | Jim Gilliam | IF-OF | |
| games) | Wally Moon | OF | |
| Charlie Neal | SS | |
| 1958 | Johnny Podres | P | Did not pitch |
| Johnny Roseboro | C | Did not play |
| 1957 | Gino Cimoli | OF | |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | |
| Clem Labine | RP | |
| 1956 | Roy Campanella | C | |
| Jim Gilliam | 2B | Did not play |
| Clem Labine | RP | Did not pitch |
| Duke Snider | OF | |
| 1955 | Roy Campanella | C | Replaced by Stan Lopata |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | |
| Don Newcombe | P | |
| Duke Snider | OF | |
| 1954 | Roy Campanella | C | |
| Carl Erskine | P | |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | Did not play |
| Jackie Robinson | 3B | |
| Duke Snider | OF | |
| 1953 | Roy Campanella | C | |
| Carl Furillo | OF | Did not play |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | |
| Jackie Robinson | 3B | |
| Duke Snider | OF | Did not play |
| 1952 | Roy Campanella | C | |
| Carl Furillo | OF | Did not play |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | Did not play |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | |
| Jackie Robinson | 2B | |
| Preacher Roe | P | Replaced by Jim Hearn |
| Duke Snider | OF | Did not play |
| 1951 | Roy Campanella | C | |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | |
| Don Newcombe | P | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | |
| Jackie Robinson | 2B | |
| Preacher Roe | P | Did not pitch |
| Duke Snider | OF | |
| 1950 | Roy Campanella | C | |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | Did not play |
| Don Newcombe | P | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | |
| Jackie Robinson | 2B | |
| Preacher Roe | P | Did not pitch |
| Duke Snider | OF | |
| 1949 | Ralph Branca | P | Did not pitch |
| Roy Campanella | C | |
| Gil Hodges | 1B | |
| Don Newcombe | P | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | |
| Jackie Robinson | 2B | |
| Preacher Roe | P | |
| 1948 | Ralph Branca | P | Starting pitcher |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | |
| 1947 | Ralph Branca | P | Did not pitch |
| Bruce Edwards | C | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | Replaced Eddie Miller |
| Eddie Stanky | 2B | |
| Dixie Walker | OF | |
| 1946 | Kirby Higbe | P | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | Replaced by 1B Frank McCormick |
| Pete Reiser | OF | Did not play |
| Dixie Walker | OF | |
| 1945 | Hal Gregg | P | |
| Goody Rosen | OF | |
| Dixie Walker | OF | |
| 1944 | Augie Galan | OF | |
| Mickey Owen | C | Did not play |
| Dixie Walker | OF | |
| 1943 | Augie Galan | OF | |
| Billy Herman | 2B | |
| Mickey Owen | C | Did not play |
| Dixie Walker | OF | |
| 1942 | Billy Herman | 2B | |
| Joe Medwick | OF | |
| Mickey Owen | C | |
| Pee Wee Reese | SS | |
| Pete Reiser | OF | |
| Arky Vaughan | 3B | |
| Whit Wyatt | P | |
| 1941 | Dolph Camilli | 1B | Replaced by Frank McCormick |
| Billy Herman | 2B | |
| Cookie Lavagetto | 3B | |
| Joe Medwick | OF | Replaced Hank Lieber |
| Mickey Owen | C | |
| Pete Reiser | OF | |
| Whit Wyatt | P | |
| 1940 | Pete Coscarart | 2B | |
| Leo Durocher | SS | Did not play |
| Cookie Lavagetto | 3B | |
| Joe Medwick | OF | |
| Babe Phelps | C | |
| Whit Wyatt | P | |
| 1939 | Dolph Camilli | 1B | |
| Cookie Lavagetto | P | Did not play |
| Babe Phelps | C | |
| Whit Wyatt | P | Did not pitch |
| 1938 | Leo Durocher | SS | |
| Cookie Lavagetto | 3B | Did not play |
| Babe Phelps | C | Replaced by Harry Danning |
| 1937 | Van Mungo | P | |
| 1936 | Van Mungo | P | Did not pitch |
| 1934 | Al Lopez | C | |
| Van Mungo | P | |
| 1933 | Tony Cuccinello | 2B | |