Boston Globe April, 1993

Plenty of heart, not much plot in The Sandlot
By: Jay Carr, Globe Staff
MOVIE REVIEW THE SANDLOT Directed by: David Mickey Evans Screenplay by: Evans, Robert Gunter Starring: Tom Guiry, Mike Vitar, Patrick Renna, Chauncey Leopardi, Marty York, Brandon Adams, Grant Gelt, Shane Obedzinski, Victor DiMattia, Art La Fleur, Denis Leary, Karen Allen, James Earl Jones Playing at: Copley Place, suburbs Rated: PG (language, kids chewing tobacco)
A steady diet of soft lobs ultimately defeat "The Sandlot," David Mickey Evans' nostalgic look at boyhood bonding over baseball, circa 1962. Still, you never are inclined to competely reject the film, even with its shortcomings. It's lacking in eventfulness and drama, but there's a sweetness in it that places it a cut above most synthetic children's films. As a writer and director, Evans doesn't always know where to go with his material, but at least there's some feeling behind it, and this sometimes rescues it from its becalmed predictability.
It's more interested in mythifying the rituals of boyhood than in achieving believability as it transforms a gawky 12-year-old into a miraculously coordinated ballplayer after only a couple of hints from the star of the sandlot team, who happens to be such a nice guy that he hits the ball right into the new kid's glove. The point of view is that of an older man looking back on his boyhood, which makes for some awkward voiceovers, but also adds mellowness and charm as the kids in the new neighborhood are presented as pretty innocent themselves, and far from formidable despite their carefully copied tough talk and spitting.
In fact, the new kid, played by Tom Guiry, fits in amazingly quickly and well, even if you do choke over his ability to become an instant ballplayer after being unable to catch or throw a ball. We don't believe in the transformation, but we do believe in the kindness of the team leader, played by Mike Vitar, and that these Valley kids are meandering through their last pure baseball summer before their thoughts turn away from horsehide and toward girls. The sandlot kids have fun squashing a snotty Little League team, and the new kid invites trouble by using his father's ball bearing Babe Ruth's autograph, but that's about it for storyline.
There's a certain long, lazy summer appeal in "The Sandlot," but while it's long on atmosphere, it's short on everything else, and forces the kids to spend an inordinate amount of time figuring out how to retrieve the Babe Ruth ball from a yard inhabited by a big, mean junkyard dog who shows up in toothy silhouette against a translucent corrugated plastic fence looking like an ad for "Jurassic Park." The film takes a long time arriving at its pretty predictable resolution, mastiff jaws and all. Yearning to be "The Natural" of the "Stand By Me" set, it falls short. But it's in there pitching, and in ways you can't hate even as you wish it had thrown a few more high hard ones.

Copyright © 1993 Globe Newspaper Company